Like most posters on this thread I've found the Leaf has become our default choice. I didn't expect my wife to like it as much as she does. I think she mainly likes minimizing her trips to the gas station, not because of the cost or even environmental concerns, but just because it is something of a pain and she doesn't like the smell or having to get dirty cleaning the windshield of her Acura. She also likes the nice big cargo area with easy access for grocery shopping, especially at Costco. She mostly knows my schedule and won't take it if she knows I'm likely to go out with it, but may ask if it's OK. Another consideration is the audio. I don't like having to switch to her car because I am usually in the middle of a CD book and it's a pain to swap CDs and find the right place twice, or, alternatively, she sometimes lets the CD play a minute or so before she switches to her radio station, so when I get back in I've missed a bit of the story and have to go back.
But I have no compunction taking the ICE when necessary. Friday we drove to the North Bay (65 mi. each way with no place to charge) in the Acura to promote my novel and figured I probably used up a month's worth of royalties just in gas!