I'd have to call it a draw. They were very close on everything except price, and CNET cheated on price. Of course no one knows what the price of the Volt is yet, but they quoted the often heard value of "under thirty thousand after tax credit". Then they turned around and called it $38,000! They also quoted the $32,800 number for the Leaf, but I'm coming to think of that as a teaser number, since it looks like the SV is going to be in very limited supply and will not include DC charging. So the real number should be $33,700. The Volt is still likely to cost more, but maybe only about 10% more. I'd rate that as one point, not the two they unfairly gave it.