Official California PG&E Thread

My Nissan Leaf Forum

Help Support My Nissan Leaf Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Here are some fundamentals on mandatory PG & E rates (tariffs) if you are charging an electric vehicle. First. PG&E's introductory summary sheet on EV charging rates:

http://www.pge.com/about/environment/pge/electricvehicles/fuelrates/index.shtml

Currently you must switch from your present rate structure (E1 for standard residential, or E6 etc for solar PV) to one of two "experimental" time-of-use rates if you charge an electric vehicle at home. These TOU rates are called E9A and E9B. Here are some things to watch out for:

Tariff E9A charges your EV through your regular home service meter. This means that your EV charging will move your whole house electricity rate up a tier or so (about 300kWh) for every 1000 miles you drive per month. In addition, existing daytime electricity use is substantially penalized in the summer - if you use air conditioning regularly, you'll pay much more per month under tariff E9A even without any EV charging. In general, you'll pay much more for EV charging under E9A than is shown on the PG&E introductory summary sheet.

Tariff E9B charges your EV through a separate service meter, starting over at its own baseline tiering level. Your house can stay on tariff E1, retaining your present electricity rate structure. This can be much more cost-effective than E9A. However, you must have the second meter installed at your own expense, which can range from about $500 to more than $10,000 depending on your existing service entry panel and utility feed. San Francisco does not allow a second meter to be installed.

If you want to ask PG&E for more information, their Clean Air Vehicle Hotline will normally return your call within about 24 hours: (800) 684-4648

EDIT: added San Francisco second meter prohibition
 
trentr said:
in regards to installing a second meter, why can't pge use those smart meters to determine TOU?

That's exactly the conversation I had with the responsive and informed rep at PG&E's clean air vehicle hotline. Some more phone calls might help ;)

It doesn't seem to make sense to invest a substantial sum to re-do a perfectly functional service entry to add a redundant meter, when a few lines of software at PG&E should do the job.
 
trentr said:
in regards to installing a second meter, why can't pge use those smart meters to determine TOU?
They could. But (my limited knowledge tells me) I don't think those meters can (yet) tell the difference between a car charging and you doing laundry or hot tub. So ... that would not allow EV charging to be incentivized.
 
The second meter in E9B would be a TOD meter, used primarily for your late-night EV charging.

Yes, they could easily have a E9C with one TOD meter, charging the E1 tiered rates for all except the late-night (the EV charging period) usage. Yes, you might occasionally dry laundry after midnight, ... !

But, they can charge you so MUCH MORE with the incredibly high E9A daytime rates, ... because they can "get away" with it, and they have a monopoly.

Perhaps with E9A (one TOD meter) one can charge the car (and maybe a spare battery pack, or two) at late-night rates, then, to keep the e-fuel "fresh", use those battery packs to run the house, and drive the meter backward during the high-rate times of the day?
Buy Low, sell High!
 
LEAFer said:
trentr said:
in regards to installing a second meter, why can't pge use those smart meters to determine TOU?
They could. But (my limited knowledge tells me) I don't think those meters can (yet) tell the difference between a car charging and you doing laundry or hot tub.
Huh? My limited knowledge has me really puzzled, now. How could a smart meter ever tell the difference between a car charging at 240v and a dryer running at 240v? Are you thinking of some new kind of "smart dryer" that communicates with the smart meter? Or maybe some kind of gadget between the dryer plug and the wall outlet? What about hardwired devices that last 25 years, like electric ranges? Are we all going to have to switch to "smart breaker boxes"?
 
Yes, exactly. I know some personnel at SMUD. This is the "future" they are talking about. In particular they are working on programs that -- if you opt-in and as an incentive they give you a "discount" of some sort -- allows the utility to turn off your A/C (not the rest of the house) during peak time ! Remotely. :shock: In the name of "greenergy" ... ok ... in the name of 1984 ... ???
With EV's on their own separate meter it would be a piece of cake ... they can "throttle" power supplied thru that one meter. So if you plan (or forgot to) charge and it happens during peak time ... guess what ...

P.S.: This could also go in a SMUD thread.
 
I forgot to say that to me, the second meter is a way for PG&E to restart the EV-charging energy billing from a baseline level, rather than from the tier that the rest of the house is at, without having to do anything at their end. Seems like they could do that with a software change by having two tiering structures, one from midnight to 6AM and the regular tiering from 6AM to midnight. But it's much easier for PG&E to just tell us to put in another meter. You have to amortize the cost of the second meter into your EV-charging electricity cost (say for a few years) to come up with a true total.
 
take a look at this great excel app
http://www.keepandshare.com/doc/804727/pgerates2-1-xls-september-16-2008-5-15-am-357k?dn=y

It will help you simulate you energy bill using EV and/or PV with E1 , E6 and E9 rates.

In my case , with a 5.0kw system, It will cost less with E9 than E6.

Two things to pay attention to in the file.
- You need to update the rates as this file is from 2008
- The KW estimated are for best condition .I had to use 4.2 for the Solar array size to reflect the actual power output of my system
 
Not sure E9 makes sense based on my solar production and I may just do my own EVSE.
 
I gave Mr. Eberhard's EV charging cost spreadsheet a go and found that it underestimated my current yearly electricity bill under E1 rates by about $300. Yes, I carefully input the current PG&E rates, rate zone, etc.

It would be off further with the addition of a Leaf to charge.

The error is greatest in the summer months. I think the reason is that the spreadsheet attempts to model electricity consumption using 6-month averages of winter and summer use. This works OK in the winter, where my electricity usage does not vary much month-to-month. But it is not very accurate for the summer months, where my electricity use peaks sharply in July, August, and September. The issue is that PG&E rates are highly tiered (nonlinear). So those few months of high energy use kick my bill up in a way that average usage does not account for. That is, average usage does not correctly calculate average costs where the rate is tiered. It works fine only when you stay within a particular tier level.

To be more accurate, the spreadsheet would need to use a month-by-month input for electricity use, and calculate a cost (bill) for each month, instead of just a winter average bill and and summer average bill.
 
If you have solar rates E-6 or E-7 you can keep them even with a BEV. The PGE rate schedule E-9 is only required if you are currently on E-1 (residential rate no TOU) and have a BEV registered with the DMV. Here is the E-9 tariff book. Read first sentence.

http://www.pge.com/tariffs/tm2/pdf/ELEC_SCHEDS_E-9.pdf
 
For new solar installations (e.g. me), E9 has much lower off-peak rates than E6 off-peak rates, almost by half, reducing EV charging costs. Peak and part-peak rates are not too different. Depending on your energy use pattern, it could be that E9 with solar is cheaper than E6 with solar.
 
Just checked with the PG&E E-9 rate specialist Adam. Switching to E-9 is optional but recommended.

So if the costs work for you then switch to E-9 if not then stay with your current rate E-1, E-6 or E-7.

For me I plan on staying with E-7 so I don't have peak from 6PM to 9PM weekdays which are high energy times for me and little to no solar generation.
 
For us solar newbies, the available E6 rate has a summer peak extending until 7pm. Fortunately my panels will be pointed west, toward the sunset.
 
Note that the E6 rate schedule has a summer peak period that starts at 1:00 PM. The E9 rate schedule starts that period at 2:00 PM. That is an hour of near peak solar production that is paid at a significantly lower rate when on E9. The actual peak rates are not very different. The off peak rate for E9 is much lower than E6 as others have pointed out. This saves money when the EV is charged at night. Details determine which is better. In my case, I estimate that E6 is better for me. This could be different if you have air conditioning, which I do not.
 
trentr said:
in regards to installing a second meter, why can't pge use those smart meters to determine TOU?
I seem to remember reading a post somewhere here on MyNissanLeaf linking to a document that described ways to possibly use additional smart meters down stream from the service entrance smart meter. I even think it was from PG&E and I can't find it now for the life of me. Anybody know what I am talking about?
 
Spies said:
I seem to remember reading a post somewhere here on MyNissanLeaf linking to a document that described ways to possibly use additional smart meters down stream from the service entrance smart meter. I even think it was from PG&E and I can't find it now for the life of me. Anybody know what I am talking about?
Or was it TED, The Energy Detective ?
 
LEAFer said:
Or was it TED, The Energy Detective ?
I suppose that did sound kinda vague. Thanks LEAFer but no it was not TED. At first I thought you were talking about Technology Entertainment and Design.

Anyway the document I am thinking of had diagrams of deploying smart meters for time of use billing by PG&E for electric car use. This way a smart meter could be installed right at the EVSE and used to only meter EV charging and allow the rest of the home to be metered separately by just subtracting what the EV used. This could avoid the costs of installing two meters at the service entrance and running a separate line to the EVSE. It would also allow someone like me to choose the E-9 Rate B (EV only) instead of the E-9 Rate A (whole house) I have now because of install restrictions.
 
Back
Top