What is Hx?

My Nissan Leaf Forum

Help Support My Nissan Leaf Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

TickTock

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 5, 2011
Messages
1,701
Location
Queen Creek, Arizona
.. or what is 7bb, Group 1, D2:D2
I realized this was a little off-topic for the "Data from the Leaf Battery App" thread so starting a new one here:
TickTock said:
OK. Jeremy shared his CANary logs so I was able to add data from a car with significantly different ESR (he's around 90mO and I'm around 120mO). Was able to fit something fairly close if I included ESC (=1/ESR), AHr, and Temperature.

If I only use ESC, below is the closest fit I could reach:
file.php

(the step function at the end of the graph is where my car's data ends and Jeremy's begins)

Adding Pack temperature to the formula it gets better:
file.php


And finally adding Ah I get the best fit (I should clarify. This is the Ah capacity (proportional to SOH) - NOT the charge state) :
file.php


Adding SOC had very little impact to the fit.
So the Fn I have now is:
Fn = 0.00616*(ESC+84.5) * [1-0.0011*(PackT-1.536)] * [1+0.0322*(Ah-49.4)]

Plugging in ttweed's data, assuming a pack temperature of 29C, and solving for ESC, it appears he has ~120mO ESR (TT, do you know your pack temp?). mwalsh's numbers don't compute because we know the Hx algorithm changed significantly with the P3227 update which he has avoided.

Any other CANary owners (or LEAFers with other means to measure ESR) willing to share their triplogs so we can see if this formula holds up under further scrutiny?
 
I tried just ESC and AH and got the following:

HxComp_ESC_Ah.jpg

Almost as good as the one with temperature also included. (RSS=.242 versus .188 for all three). Probably because AH is already modulated with temperature. So from this is appears Hx is a metric including *both* ESR and SOH (SOH is proportional to AH). In the graph, Hx is the value read from the Leaf and Hx2 is my formula. Currently:
Hx2 = 0.00595*(ESC+84.5) * [1+0.0320*(Ah-49.2)]
 
Very nice work.
The formula with temperature fits your data really well.

Perhaps the thread title should be "Investigating Hx", or similar
rather than What is..?

Maybe you could detail exactly what data is being used for the
calculation. Thanks.

What is your horizontal axis, trips?

Cheers, Gary
 
Back
Top